While soda has long been seen as pizza’s classic drink partner, juice enthusiasts know the right pairing can lift a slice to new heights. At OpenPlainRegistry, we’ve teamed up with local experts to craft juice recommendations that harmonize with our menu. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeaway, these suggestions will help you discover the perfect juice for your favorite pizza style.
Classic Margherita: Tomato Basil Juice or Pomegranate Blend
The simplicity of a Margherita—fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil—asks for a juice that won’t overpower the delicate notes. A homemade tomato basil juice provides bright acidity that echoes the tomatoes while adding enough structure to support the cheese. Alternatively, a light-bodied pomegranate blend delivers red fruit nuances that amplify the tomatoes’ sweetness and complement the herbaceous basil.
Our specific recommendation: We love pairing our Margherita with our signature Tomato Basil Cooler or, for something sweeter, a locally-sourced Pomegranate Blueberry blend.
Pepperoni and Meat Lovers: Spiced Cherry or Blackcurrant
Pizzas loaded with cured meats like pepperoni, sausage, or prosciutto need juices with body and spice to match bold flavors. Spiced cherry juice, with its jammy fruit character and peppery finish, pairs beautifully with the saltiness and heat of meat toppings. As an alternative, try blackcurrant juice for rustic dark fruit notes and a tangy finish that cuts through the richness.
Our specific recommendation: Our customers particularly enjoy our house-made Spiced Cherry Elixir or Organic Blackcurrant Supreme with our Meat Feast pizza.
Mushroom and Truffle: Beetroot or Forest Berry
The earthy, umami-rich flavors of mushrooms and truffles call for juices with similar notes. Beetroot juice offers subtle earthy aromas that complement fungi, with a touch of sweetness to balance the richness. A forest berry blend also works well, developing complex berry tones that mirror the earthiness of the pizza.
Our specific recommendation: Try our Wild Mushroom pizza with Cold-Pressed Beetroot Juice or Wild Forest Berry Medley.
Seafood Pizza: Citrus Splash or Sea Buckthorn
For pizzas featuring prawns, clams, or other seafood, crisp juices with mineral notes are ideal partners. A citrus blend provides refreshing lift that enhances seafood flavors, while sea buckthorn juice offers high acidity, a tropical vibe, and a subtle tartness that won’t overwhelm delicate seafood.
Our specific recommendation: Our Mediterranean Seafood pizza pairs beautifully with our Citrus Splash or Organic Sea Buckthorn Nectar.
Vegetable Supreme: Green Detox or Cucumber Melon
Vegetable-topped pizzas benefit from versatile, herbal-forward juices. A green detox juice with spinach, celery, and apple echoes and enhances the flavors of peppers, artichokes, and other vegetables. Cucumber melon juice provides light freshness and a gentle body that stands up to various vegetable textures without overpowering them.
Our specific recommendation: Our Garden Harvest pizza finds perfect harmony with Daily Green Detox or Chilled Cucumber Melon Refresh.
Four Cheese Pizza: Creamy Almond or Sparkling Apple
The richness of a four-cheese pie calls for either a complementary or contrasting approach. A creamy almond milk offers nutty notes that echo the cheese blend. For contrast, try a sparkling apple juice—its effervescence and acidity cut through the richness and its fruity profile provides a pleasant counterpoint to the savory cheeses.
Our specific recommendation: Our Quattro Formaggi pizza pairs wonderfully with Vanilla Almond Milk or Sparkling Apple Crisp.
Spicy Pizzas: Mango Lassi or Ginger Turmeric
When pizzas feature chili flakes, spicy sausage, or hot honey, creamy or zesty juices provide welcome relief. Mango lassi cools the palate with a creamy texture between bites. Ginger turmeric juice also stands up to heat while delivering interesting flavor contrast and potential anti-inflammatory benefits.
Our specific recommendation: Our Spicy Diavola pizza finds its match in Homemade Mango Lassi or Firefly Ginger Turmeric Boost.
Dessert Pizza: Berry Smoothie or Chocolate Almond
For those adventurous enough to try our Nutella and fruit dessert pizzas, sweet juices are essential. Mixed berry smoothies complement fruit-topped dessert pies, while chocolate almond milk makes a divine pairing with chocolate-hazelnut variations. The key is ensuring the drink is at least as sweet as the dessert.
Our specific recommendation: Our Nutella and Strawberry Dessert Pizza pairs heavenly with Triple Berry Blast or Dark Chocolate Almond Milk.
Tips for Pizza and Juice Pairing
- Consider the dominant flavor on the pizza, not just the crust or sauce
- High-acid juices generally work well with tomato-based pizzas due to the tomatoes’ natural acidity
- Fizzing juices are versatile options that suit nearly any pizza
- Don’t be afraid to experiment—unexpected combinations can create memorable moments
At OpenPlainRegistry, we’ve expanded our juice list to include many of these recommended pairings. Our staff is always happy to suggest the perfect juice for your pizza choice. We also offer juice flight options that let you sample three different juices alongside your meal.
Remember, while these guidelines can help steer you toward harmonious pairings, personal taste always wins. The best juice to pair with your pizza is the one you enjoy drinking!